Customers praised the 100% organic cotton material, saying it's "so comfortable" and doesn't irritate. However, sizing is inconsistent and unpredictable across colors. Several shoppers found them too small or tight, with some hearing threads rip. Many recommend sizing up, especially if using a dryer as shrinkage occurs. Price point is high, with return shipping fees noted.

Material (positive)Color (positive)Comfort (positive)Colors (positive)Cotton (positive)
  • 5 stars: 5 (56%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (11%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (11%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 2 (22%)
C
C.
5 / Pebble Melange Brown
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: eczema, elastic/latex allergy
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Comfortable, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Favorites despite minor sizing issues

Size 5 in Gray previous was a bit too large, so I tried Size 4, and they are a bit too small. It turns out that Size 5 in Black first best from a previous order. So, sizing is a bit unpredictable, and I think it might be safer to get size 5 for this item. Other than that, I appreciate that the elastic is covered and the material is organic cotton.

J
J.L.
7 / Heather Grey
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: lycra allergy
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Sensitive Skin, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
bikini brief

love the all cotton

C
C.
6 / Deep Melange Blue
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: Contact dermatitis
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Allergic Contact Dermatitis
Great product, but expensive

I bought a size 6 after checking my measurements against the website's recommended size chart. However, since there is no elastic in the bands it seems to be a bit tight getting them on and off and I can hear ripping threads if I'm not careful. I didn't want to deal with paying a shipping fee to return them (which is kind of crappy considering the price of the products) so I'll make do, but I would say take the sizing chart with a grain of salt. It's 100% cotton so there's also the possibility that they will shrink more in the wash. Not sure if I'll buy again considering how expensive they were.

L
L.
6 / Deep Melange Blue
Fit: True To Size
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Comfortable, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities, Others
Worth the price

I enjoy the new colors for these types of underwear and like better than the original colors because they are more vivid. Since I use a dryer machine, I bought a size bigger than what would be my size, because they do shrink a bit in the drying machine. If you hang up your clothes to naturally dry, your size without sizing up or down should be fine. All women should be wearing organic cotton or some other form of natural fabric for underwear for health reasons, it really makes a difference.

T
T.S.
5 / Melange Black
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: Send bigger ones..I will be throwing them away.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy
Too small

They were way too smalk

V
V.P.
7 / Deep Melange Blue
Very comfortable underwear

I really like the deep blue color. They are so comfortable and it is so hard to find 100 percent cotton underwear. Nearly all our mixed fiber and can be irritating.

S
S.A.
7 / Melange Black
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: returning
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
size

did not fit

h
h.d.i.d.s.o.s.
5 / Pebble Melange Brown
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: allergic to mercapto mix and formaldehyde
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Formaldehyde-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
So nice not to itch

So nice to find garments that dont make me itch

Hi Randi,

Thank you for the 5-star rating! We truly appreciate your support and are so glad you're satisfied with your experience.
Your feedback means a lot to us, and we look forward to serving you again.
Feel free to reach out if you need anything else.

L
L.S.

These melange brown shrunk more than other pair and should size up but fit well!

"Finally, clothing your body can trust."

Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
$50.00 USD
Men’s Elasticized Woven Boxer Shorts
$30.00 USD
Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts
$30.00 USD
Front view of a blue organic cotton crop top bralette for sensitive skin
Back view of a blue melange organic cotton crop top with wide straps, allergy-friendly design
Women's 100% Organic Cotton Rib Bra Liner
$30.00 USD