Customers praised these boxers as "extremely comfortable" with full cotton construction and drawstring waist. Many loved the loose fit and freedom from elastic. However, quality consistency issues emerged, with some reporting sizing discrepancies in leg width, waistband fit, and drawstring stitching variations across different pairs.

Comfort (positive)Quality (positive)Materials (positive)Cotton (positive)Fit (neutral)
  • 5 stars: 7 (64%)
  • 4 stars: 3 (27%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (9%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
D
D.
S/M / Deep Melange Blue
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: chronic fatigue
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Dye / Bleach Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Drawstring is the key

Pure cotton with a drawstring is hard to find. I cannot tolerate a tight band around my waist. Only issue I have with the drawstring on these boxers is that it’s a tad narrow, and has more of a cord profile than a flat profile, which means it digs in a bit. Otherwise the fit is good. And the various certifications eg GOTS = clean and healthy. Though, I was surprised by the chemical stink coming out of the package when first opened

A
A.D.
L/XL / Deep Melange Blue
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: I need drawstrings and not elastic around my waist. I wish they had men's brushed cotton pyjamas with drawstrings and no elastic.
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable

Men's Drawstring Loose Boxer Shorts

A
Anonymous
L/XL / Heather Grey
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: N/A.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Comfortable, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Very comfortable

Very comfortable. Hubby loves them.

A
Anonymous
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: None
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable, Others
Very comfortable!

Very comfortable! I love the full Cotton construction as well, im hopeful these will last much much longer than any previous boxers of mine.

Y
Y.M.
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Avoiding synthetics and chemicals
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable, Sensitive Skin, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities, Others
Overall happy with them

Overall happy with them. I couldn't get on with using drawstrings the whole time, but that's not an issue with these specific boxers.

E
E.I.
L/XL / Melange Black
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: None. Prefer cotton, bamboo, and modal clothing
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable, Others
Too comfortable

Extremely comfortable and good substitute for tight underwear

B
B.W.
L/XL / Melange Black
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: No acute conditions; just trying to stick to healthy materials
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Others
Great product if only they had the QA to match

I bought a few pairs of these and loved those first pairs. But as I've bought more pairs I've seen many issues with consistency: two pairs had a fly button positioned so that my junk is constantly hanging out. Another several pairs were far too small around the legs even though I've only ever ordered one size. Those pairs also had the drawstring stitched differently than the others: for those pairs, the drawstring was sandwiched between two stitch lines, while the pairs that I've liked had the drawstring in the pocket above two stitch lines. The good pairs of these are the best underwear I've ever owned. But the bad pairs are unwearable.

Thanks for leaving a review of the Boxer Shorts.. Appreciate your feedback and sorry about the issues with some of the pairs. We strive for consistency in our products and apologize for this issue.

We would like to make this right for you. Please kindly provide photos or a video of the differences you have noticed in the fly button and drawstring placement so we can have this addressed in our production or product design immediately. We will review the evidence and send over a replacement for the unsatisfactory pairs. Could you please send the email to customerservice@cottonique.com and address it to Nik. Thanks..

We want to ensure you have the best experience with our products, also your comment: 'The good pairs of these are the best underwear I've ever owned' is so nice to hear. Thank you for bringing this to our attention and we look forward to resolving this for you to to gain confidence in this product again. We are going to fix this issue right away.

Best,
Nik
Co-founder

P
P.T.
2XL/3XL / Deep Melange Blue
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Latex allergy.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy
Good for intended purpose

Works as it always has.

J
J.P.

Soft and comfortable. Fits well in the legs, but big waist.

I
I.M.
S/M / Melange Black
Fit: Too large
Conditions: None personal preference
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
Amazing

Not only you know you are not exposing your body to harsh chemicals, they are also comfortable. Not having elastic around the waist feels like freedom.

M
M.S.
S/M / Melange Black
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Sensitive skin
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Others
Natural Boxer Shorts

Quality materials and effortless comfort combine for a wonderful pair of boxer shorts!

"Finally, clothing your body can trust."

Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
$50.00 USD
Men’s Elasticized Woven Boxer Shorts
$30.00 USD
Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts
$30.00 USD
Front view of a blue organic cotton crop top bralette for sensitive skin
Back view of a blue melange organic cotton crop top with wide straps, allergy-friendly design
Women's 100% Organic Cotton Rib Bra Liner
$30.00 USD