Customers praised the thermal shirt as "warm and very comfortable" with soft fabric and good insulation. However, sizing issues are common—many noted it runs small overall with sleeves that are "too short." Some customers raised concerns about material composition and cotton authenticity. Best for those who size up for proper fit.

Fabric (positive)Comfort (positive)Fit (neutral)Material (neutral)Cotton (negative)
  • 5 stars: 3 (25%)
  • 4 stars: 4 (33%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (8%)
  • 2 stars: 1 (8%)
  • 1 star: 3 (25%)
N
N.S.
Large / Black
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: avoiding questionable chemicals (not allergic, just health-conscious)
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly
What made you choose Cottonique?: Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
:)

:)

W
W.
Large / Black
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: Chemical Free Clothing
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Comfortable, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Men's Thermal Base Layer Long Sleeve Shirt

Warm and very comfortable, liked it! The only issue is the size. I ordered size L, but this shirt fits a little too small, like size M, so I only wear it at home. Will order size XL or 2XL for outdoor wear.

E
E.
Medium / Black
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Sensitive skin, acne prone
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis
Cozy and comfy

The fabric is soft and comfortable. It insulates well. My only complaint is that, as others have noted, the sleeves are a little short. I’m 5’9”, 150 lb (slim/athletic) and overall, a size M fits well but the sleeves shorter than I would like. I have had other thermal base layer-type shirts like this from other brands that also have sleeves on the shorter side. Perhaps this is intentional so it doesn’t show when worn under shirts/sweaters. It fits well enough for me to be worth keeping, but it you want sleeves on the longer side, I’d recommend sizing up.

J
J.C.
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: Allergies
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Polyester wrapped?!?!

These garments are not safe with polyester core, wrapped or not, and it is false advertising to say these products are 100% organic cotton. They also run small. If the thread is not 100% organic cotton, it is 100% false.

M
M.S.
Medium / Black
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: None
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Others
Okay

The material is fine but both the pants and top are at least 1 inch short. I am 5'8" and weigh 165 lbs and have been wearing mediums forever and they fit perfect. These as stated run short - nice otherwise, I would order large if you normally wear medium.

Hi Michael! Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding our Men's Thermal Base Layer Long Sleeve Shirt. We appreciate your input.

We apologize for any inconvenience caused by the sizing issue. Your feedback about the length being shorter than expected is noted, and we'll take it into consideration for future improvements to ensure a better fit for our customers.

Your satisfaction is important to us, and we're committed to providing high-quality products that meet your needs. If you have any further feedback or questions, please feel free to reach out to us. Thank you for choosing Cottonique!

S
S.
2X-Large / Black
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: Warmth and comfort
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
Perfect Except

It seems to run somewhat smaller than other brands of shirts.

S
S.R.
Large / Black
Sleeve too short

The sleeve on the size Large is very short. I'm 5'11". I would say it is 3" short. I'm giving it to my wife. I've never seen a large sleeve this short, and it's really short.

A
Anonymous
Medium / Black
Very comfy material

I love the material. I found the rise in the bottoms to be a bit too low and the length of the top a bit too short.

L
L.
2X-Large / Black
Too much plastic

I admire the fact that Cottonique commits to non-synthetic, all natural, organic clothing. But, the amount of plastic they use when shipping their products is ridiculous. Clothing does not need extra plastic air pillows - it's not breakable. The products I received were sealed in plastic and then padded with more plastic. Entirely unnecessary.

T
T.S.
Large / Black
Very comfortable

This is the first time we purchased this item. My husband wore it the next day. He said it is so comfortable and fits so well.

J
J.M.
2X-Large / Black
Not 100% Cotton

I purchased several hundred dollars of 100% cotton clothing from Cottonique, and when laundered it all stuck together, with a lot of static electricity. Obviously this is not 100% cotton. I am allergic to synthetics, so the clothing is useless to me.

M
M.
Medium / Black
Great for PJs or under layer

Updated review: Warmer than plain cotton. Fits true to size and stretchy so remains comfortable and non binding. Husband likes it a lot

B
B.J.

Hi, all of your products seem to say they are 100% cotton but then when I look at the product care notes e.g. for the thermal cotton tops in black, say, it says the thread has a polyester core! How can it then be 100% cotton! Please can you explain what is going on - thank you Brian

Cottonique

Hello Brian! Cottonique Products are 100% Organic Cotton fabric. All NATURAL colored products are completely dye-free, unbleached, chemical-free, latex-free and spandex free. While we have used less harsh dyes for our Cottonique COLORED Collection which are also latex-free and spandex free.
These products are intended specifically for individuals with sensitivities to Latex, Spandex, and Formaldehyde.

For our Natural colored items, we use 100% cotton thread to sew the stitching.

For our colored items, we use premium quality core spun thread to sew the stitching that combines a high-tenacity polyester filament core with a natural cotton cover. It is a cotton-wrapped polyester core thread.

The actual percentage of polyester core thread in our colored items is only a maximum of 1% per garment. To this, if you're unsure of the thread in our colored items, you can just opt for the natural-colored items instead.
For our Natural colored items, we use 100% cotton thread.

"Finally, clothing your body can trust."

Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
475,00 kr
Men’s Elasticized Woven Boxer Shorts
285,00 kr
Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts
285,00 kr
Front view of a blue organic cotton crop top bralette for sensitive skin
Back view of a blue melange organic cotton crop top with wide straps, allergy-friendly design
Women's 100% Organic Cotton Rib Bra Liner
285,00 kr