Customers praised the 100% organic cotton fabric as "very soft" and "comfortable," especially for sensitive skin and allergies. The flat elastic waistband prevents lines under clothing. However, sizing runs inconsistent—some found them too small, others too large. Common complaints include seams that irritate or rub, leg openings that are too tight or loose, and elastic odor issues for some shoppers.

Fabric (positive)Skin (positive)Waist (positive)Comfort (positive)Cotton (positive)
  • 5 stars: 30 (50%)
  • 4 stars: 11 (18%)
  • 3 stars: 12 (20%)
  • 2 stars: 2 (3%)
  • 1 star: 5 (8%)
A
Anonymous
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: I like natural fabrics
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
Elasticized Boxer Brief

These boxer briefs have an elastic waist so they lay more flat than briefs with a drawstring... good for under clothing items that are such that a drawstring would show. They run very small and they have a low waist, IMO they are cut just a bit too low in the waist. They are made from all cotton, and are spandex free so they are comfortable. Compared to Cottonique's drawstring boxers for women, these elasticized boxer briefs run very small, while the drawstring boxers run quite large. These elasticized boxer briefs have a lower waist than the drawstring boxers. These elasticized boxer briefs have a flattering slim fit cut, better for wearing under slim fit clothing or clothing made of lightweight fabric; while the drawstring boxers have a relaxed cut, good for optimal comfort.

M
M.O.
7 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: I like smooth natural fabrics
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
Soft and Comfortable

These boxers are made from 1x1 rib cotton rather than the single jersey cotton that women' briefs and boy briefs are made from. I like how smooth the single jersey cotton is so wasn't sure I'd like these boxers as much as the boy briefs, however the 1x1 rib cotton is very soft and the texture subtle. The fabric is very comfortable. I found the boy briefs less low rise than they appear in the online photo, the rise in those seems more medium than low. I like the fit of the boy briefs. These boxers are as low rise as they appear in the photo. The fit is flattering, and with the elastic waist they lay flat so they are good for wearing under clothing that would show a drawstring waist. I'm pleased with these boxers.

A
Anonymous
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Sensitive
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
Comfy

Comfy

A
Anonymous
6 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: skin problems and heat sensitivity
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Excelllent! will buy again!

very comfortable fit and fabric. love the colour/shade as well and no panty lines

C
C.K.T.
8 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
My Favorites!

Love the boxer -type pants, especially in white

k
k.r.
4 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: No at all
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Sensitive Skin
Stitching

Because of very poor quality of thread for the stitching I am obliged to wear my underwear INSIDE OUT !

K
K.M.
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Sensitivity to Chemicals
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Sensitive Skin
So glad you brought in Elasticized Boxer Briefs for Women

I have always loved women's boxer briefs. The way they cover the top of thigh is comfortable for me. And having them 100% Organic Cotton is such a gift.

Thank you

M
M.N.
9 / Natural
Love the fabric

Very comfortable fabric, but the seams can be uncomfortable/itchy so I wear inside out. I use as sleep shorts, so it doesn't matter.

G
G.
5 / Natural
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: I just love all cotton undergarments that are very simple and cottonIque fits the bill
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
Fit issue for me

Hi, I’ve love this brand and everything I have from them is perfect. However, these panties did not fit me properly. A size 6 was too large in the body, but fit in the leg, a size 5 fit in the body, but the stitching was too tight on my legs. And I think my legs are fairly slim. I was really disappointed as a boy short is the type of panty I always wear and was so happy to see that Cottonique had the style.

R
R.
9 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: I am allergic to lots of elastics and even to bandages if ever used. Your cotton pants are very neutral.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Sensitive Skin
Very comfy but as cotton, it is by nature going to expand a bit while wearing

There is no such thing as true to size!! We are women. What I got is pretty darn good. So I am saying true to size. I don't have much of a waistline but it could be a tad tighter.

Hi Robin,
Thank you so much for your feedback! We're glad to hear you're happy with the fit overall. We appreciate you sharing your thoughts. Thanks again for sharing, and we hope you continue to enjoy your purchase!

L
L.D.B.
8 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Allergic contact dermatitis.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Allergic Contact Dermatitis
Relief

My journey to healing started 7 months ago when I was first diagnosed with allergic contact dermatitis to mercaptobenzothiazole (all things rubber related). The elastic in my underwear was causing my skin to become extremely raw. After much research I discovered Cottonique and ordered the Women's Elasticized Boxer Brief (2/Pack). The legs have no elastic so my skin is able to heal, the top portion, where there is elastic, is covered by material that has not affected my skin. Thank you Cottonique!

J
J.C.
5 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Chronic urticaria
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Sensitive Skin
Past customer

I wear them inside out because I can only wear French seams. Anything not flat, soft and smooth triggers a breakout.

R
R.E.
6 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Looking for ALL organic no compromise clothing
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Will be back for more!!

Soooo comfortable!! Excited to share your site with friends that will benefit knowing it's a good for your skin kind of material and so cozy!

D
D.K.
8 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Latex rash
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Sensitive Skin, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Comfy undies

By Diana Kennedy

S
S.L.
8 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: I just don’t like the constrictive feeling of traditional underwear.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Latex-Free and Spandex-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable
Just Right

I have never worn boxer briefs before, and I was a little concerned they would feel bulky underneath my clothing. These are very light and are form-fitting without being too tight. I wear them under jeans and leggings comfortably. Also, they did not shrink after being washed in hot water and put through medium setting in the dryer.

Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for our Women's Elasticized Boxer Briefs, Stephanie. We are happy to hear that you found them to be lightweight and form-fitting without feeling bulky. We pride ourselves on providing comfortable and practical options for our customers. Thank you for choosing Cottonique and for your feedback. Have a great day!

E
E.B.
9 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Allergic Contact Dermatitis to many chemicals.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Allergic Contact Dermatitis
Looks nice, not safe for Carba Mix allergy

These are probably great for those not allergic to Carba Mix. Materials are soft but unfortunately I can't wear them.

Hi Joshua, thank you for sharing your feedback regarding our Women's Elasticized Boxer Briefs. We're sorry to hear about your allergic reaction to Carba Mix and apologize for any discomfort it may have caused you.

At Cottonique, we prioritize creating allergen-free clothing options for individuals with sensitivities like yours. We understand the importance of providing safe and comfortable products, and we regret that our boxer briefs did not meet your needs in this regard.

Your feedback is invaluable to us, and we'll take it into consideration as we continue to improve our product offerings. If you have any further questions or if there's anything else we can assist you with, please don't hesitate to reach out.

Thank you for choosing Cottonique!

L
L.B.
8 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Psoriasis
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Sensitive Skin

Women's Elasticized Boxer Brief (2/Pack)

R
R.B.
9 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Allergy to latex and dyes.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Sensitive Skin
So comfortable!

I love them. They are the softest and most comfortable underwater ever.

A
A.M.
9 / Natural
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: sensitive
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Comfortable, Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Very comfy!

I just love organic and these are stretchy and comfortable too- exquisite fabric!

k
k.p.
7 / Natural

Good, best with no elastics, statics can be a problem with some fabrics.

P
P.U.
9 / Natural
Fit: Too large
Conditions: Allergic to elastic nylon and rayon
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Latex-Free and Spandex-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy
Review

I like the product. Was just too big.

"Finally, clothing your body can trust."

Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
¥8,100
Men’s Elasticized Woven Boxer Shorts
¥4,900
Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts
¥4,900
Front view of a blue organic cotton crop top bralette for sensitive skin
Back view of a blue melange organic cotton crop top with wide straps, allergy-friendly design
Women's 100% Organic Cotton Rib Bra Liner
¥4,900